Aussies land crippled A330
Moderator: Latest news team
Re: Aussies land crippled A330
I don't think I have ever seen less factual information on an incident than this one.
One report was that the engine quit and they kept on for 4 hours as "it was rated for it". Thats insane.
Others are both engine quit, apparently not true.
Origination is listed as a fuel stop, where was it coming form it needed to stop for fuel (and comments they may use Jakarta.
Only thing that seems solid is they landed hot. Really hot. Pilots certainly were not heroes. When your butt is on the line with everyone else, you are not a hero. You do something that risks your life for someone who you don't have to, that is a hero (and various forms of community service that you give up a great deal for I will add)
One report was that the engine quit and they kept on for 4 hours as "it was rated for it". Thats insane.
Others are both engine quit, apparently not true.
Origination is listed as a fuel stop, where was it coming form it needed to stop for fuel (and comments they may use Jakarta.
Only thing that seems solid is they landed hot. Really hot. Pilots certainly were not heroes. When your butt is on the line with everyone else, you are not a hero. You do something that risks your life for someone who you don't have to, that is a hero (and various forms of community service that you give up a great deal for I will add)
-
- Posts: 24
- Joined: 15 May 2007, 12:40
Re: Aussies land crippled A330
Feeling a bit frustrated?
From your post, I don't believe we read the same article.
From your post, I don't believe we read the same article.
- favourite_belgian
- Posts: 37
- Joined: 15 Apr 2005, 00:00
- Location: Antwerp, Belgium
- Contact:
Re: Aussies land crippled A330
I seem to have read a different article too. The article in the SMH doesn't mention anything about "the pilots keeping at it for four hours" or that the plane made "a fuel stop". Where do you get that information from?RC20 wrote:I don't think I have ever seen less factual information on an incident than this one.
One report was that the engine quit and they kept on for 4 hours as "it was rated for it". Thats insane.
Others are both engine quit, apparently not true.
Origination is listed as a fuel stop, where was it coming form it needed to stop for fuel (and comments they may use Jakarta.
Only thing that seems solid is they landed hot. Really hot. Pilots certainly were not heroes. When your butt is on the line with everyone else, you are not a hero. You do something that risks your life for someone who you don't have to, that is a hero (and various forms of community service that you give up a great deal for I will add)
You also seem to have a different definition of "factual". The article mentions several facts, e.g. where the plane came from, how many passengers it had on board, that eight of them were injured, the deflated tyres, etc.
Furthermore, by your definition, a pilot can never be a hero because he/she will always be saving him/herself as well.
-
- Posts: 1033
- Joined: 21 Oct 2005, 00:00
- Location: Northern Virginia USA
Re: Aussies land crippled A330
Same story or another issue?
Flight global reports: http://www.flightglobal.com/articles/20 ... oblem.html
DATE:14/04/10
SOURCE:Air Transport Intelligence news
Cathay A330 in high-energy landing had dual engine problem
By David Kaminski-Morrow
Cathay Pacific has admitted that both engines on the Airbus A330-300 which carried out a high-speed landing at Hong Kong yesterday had experienced problems.
Flight-data analysis shows the right-hand Rolls-Royce Trent 700 powerplant had been at idle thrust during the entire approach while thrust on the left-hand engine had "frozen" at 70% of maximum.
This higher thrust setting on the left-hand engine resulted in a landing at 230kt, with an incorrect flap configuration.
The high-speed landing led six of the aircraft’s tyres to deflate and, after receiving indications of flames from the heated landing-gear, the crew ordered an evacuation of the aircraft via the slides.
Cathay had previous stated that one engine had been shut down during the approach, but that the other was "functioning" – with no indication of any problems.
The airline clarifies today that "at no time" were both engines shut down in flight.
Maintenance support manager Dennis Hui says the aircraft would normally have touched down at 135kt.
Flight CX780 from Surabaya, Indonesia, landed in the correct runway position, he says: "But due to its high speed, it had to brake hard and use reverse thrust from the operating engine."
Cathay Pacific says it is co-operating with the Hong Kong Civil Aviation Department, Rolls-Royce and Airbus to establish the reasons for the powerplant problems.
Flight global reports: http://www.flightglobal.com/articles/20 ... oblem.html
DATE:14/04/10
SOURCE:Air Transport Intelligence news
Cathay A330 in high-energy landing had dual engine problem
By David Kaminski-Morrow
Cathay Pacific has admitted that both engines on the Airbus A330-300 which carried out a high-speed landing at Hong Kong yesterday had experienced problems.
Flight-data analysis shows the right-hand Rolls-Royce Trent 700 powerplant had been at idle thrust during the entire approach while thrust on the left-hand engine had "frozen" at 70% of maximum.
This higher thrust setting on the left-hand engine resulted in a landing at 230kt, with an incorrect flap configuration.
The high-speed landing led six of the aircraft’s tyres to deflate and, after receiving indications of flames from the heated landing-gear, the crew ordered an evacuation of the aircraft via the slides.
Cathay had previous stated that one engine had been shut down during the approach, but that the other was "functioning" – with no indication of any problems.
The airline clarifies today that "at no time" were both engines shut down in flight.
Maintenance support manager Dennis Hui says the aircraft would normally have touched down at 135kt.
Flight CX780 from Surabaya, Indonesia, landed in the correct runway position, he says: "But due to its high speed, it had to brake hard and use reverse thrust from the operating engine."
Cathay Pacific says it is co-operating with the Hong Kong Civil Aviation Department, Rolls-Royce and Airbus to establish the reasons for the powerplant problems.
-
- Posts: 1137
- Joined: 08 May 2007, 09:38
Re: Aussies land crippled A330
Same one.smokejumper wrote:Same story or another issue?
.