BRU-MAN with SN, MAN-BRU with BA (13 Jan 04)

Share your experiences about your latest flights: details and pictures are highly appreciated by our community. How do you rate airlines, in-flight meals, frequent flyer programs, etc... join this forum now!
User avatar
sn26567
Posts: 40845
Joined: 13 Feb 2003, 00:00
Location: Rosières/Rozieren, Belgium
Contact:

BRU-MAN with SN, MAN-BRU with BA (13 Jan 04)

Post by sn26567 »

This was a one-day return in economy class. The BA/SN codeshare monoply has pushed the prices up to a hefty €598, which is still cheaper than what LH asks for the shorter trip between BRU and FRA.

1. BRU-MAN SN2173

I arrived early at BRU airport, and checked in at an automatic machine, which never asks for the weight of my hand luggage (it was anyway more than the allowed 6 kg), and I was assigned seat 10F (the SN database remembered I prefer window seats). But I also looked at the very short queues at the SN counters. The tellers seemed to be very efficient.

During my wait, I first had an orange juice and a coffee at the Diners Club lounge (a nice feature when you have the Diners credit card and are not allowed the airline business lounges). And ten I walked around pier B to see if there was anything special.

The SLR B767 flight to Varadero and Cancun departed on time. The SN Avro RJ85 OO-DJQ still has a blue belly with Qualiflyer titles!
Image
And then I saw this Canadair OY-RJA of Danish regional airline Cimber Air:
Image
What was this plane doing in BRU? Could it be operating the Maersk/SN flights to Billund?

My plane was SN2173 departing 09.30. It was operated with an Avro RJ85 OO-DJT. On-time boarding. Load factor 60%. Usual Avro seating (five abreast, leather seats).
Image
The purser was Patrick, and he was assisted by a blonde stewardess, but no other names of crew members were mentioned. It is the first time I see only two f/a's on an SN Avro, instead of the usual three.

Due to strong winds and rain, take-off was on time but bumpy, but soon te weather cleared up and it was possible to see the Scheldt river and the North Sea. New clouds and a bumpy descent to Manchester.

Nice breakfast (orange juice or Spa water, ham and mustard sandwhich, hot croissant, tea or coffee, and two Belgian chocolates), swiftly served by smiling staff. And on-time arrival at 9:50 after an excellent 1 hr 20 min flight.

2. MAN-BRU BA1620

What a difference for the return flight! I tried to check in at a BA automatic machine, but it did not accept my ticket because it was issued under an SN number. I thus had to queue, and the line was much longer than in Brussels. I got seat 10A. I did not notice any special planes during my wait.

Boarding was on time. The aircraft was an Avro RJ100 of Bristish Airways CityExpress; I did not even bother to check the registration after I saw the seating, but it looked like this:
Image
Seating was, as I feared, 6 abreast, although with leather seats. But in C class, the seats were five abreast, and there were 7 passengers for seven rows (meaning a load factor of only 20%). In economy, for the remaining rows, load factor was 65%. That means that there should have been less rows in C and more in Y.

Nevertheless, there were two neighbours on my right side, and we were like sardines in a box. Departure was on-time at 17:30 and smoother than in the morning flight.

The meal was a single all day deli (mozzarella and onion marmelade on tomato bread: surprising, but not bad). It was quickly served, as there were no less than 4 stewardesses on board (here the number can replace the quality). With that I had a 33 cl can of the only available beer: a UK-brewed Stella Artois. That was also OK.

Brussels was reached in one hour, and after some delay at getting to the gate, I disembarked on time at 19:55.

I said "never again in an Avro with 6 seats abreast", and I confirm; but when you have in a hurry to get home and no other choice, except waiting two and a half more hours for a SN flight, what do you do?
Last edited by sn26567 on 14 Jan 2004, 15:58, edited 1 time in total.
André
ex Sabena #26567

User avatar
Comet
Posts: 6481
Joined: 05 Jul 2003, 00:00
Location: Scarborough, North Yorkshire, England
Contact:

Post by Comet »

SN2173 haha - I go on SN2174 in September!

So you drunk some fake Stella - dreadful. The Belgian variety is much better. The SN sounded good, but flying with BA - you would have been better with VLM, can't beat them.

A cabin crew of 2? I had that on my first ever Sabena flight in an Avro so it is not unique.

Instead of an Avro with 6 abreast you should have gone for a Fokker 50 with four abreast leather seats - with VLM.

EI BAe 146s were 6 abreast, but they weren't that bad.

Great report and the photos really add to it!
Sabena and Sobelair - gone but never forgotten.
Louise

User avatar
sn26567
Posts: 40845
Joined: 13 Feb 2003, 00:00
Location: Rosières/Rozieren, Belgium
Contact:

Post by sn26567 »

In that star ranking website, BA and SN both have four stars, but for economy class, SN still has four, whereas BA has only 3. For business class, both have four stars, and for first, BA has five stars. It is nice to lure high-paying passengers, but not at the expense of economy travellers.
EI BAe 146s were 6 abreast, but they weren't that bad.
Maybe for small people, but if you weigh 80 kg for 1.83 m, they are too small, whatever the airline. An Avro is built to have 5 seats abreast, not 6. And the airlines that put 6 seats are cheating their customers.
André
ex Sabena #26567

User avatar
Comet
Posts: 6481
Joined: 05 Jul 2003, 00:00
Location: Scarborough, North Yorkshire, England
Contact:

Post by Comet »

It also sounds like an expensive trip - over 500 Euros!!! My day trip with SNBA in March is costing £96.30 for a return. You are being ripped off somewhere! BA don't sound half as good as SNBA or especially VLM! At least VLM serves proper beer (Maes or Jupiler) and not fake rubbish.

But I can't believe those star ranking sites because of the rubbish written about VLM.
Sabena and Sobelair - gone but never forgotten.
Louise

User avatar
sn26567
Posts: 40845
Joined: 13 Feb 2003, 00:00
Location: Rosières/Rozieren, Belgium
Contact:

Post by sn26567 »

I just looked at the cheapest quotes on Galileo for a day-trip on 16 Jan with the flights I have taken (BA/SN codeshare) and with VLM. Amazing results:

BA: €309.12 (non-refundable)
SN: €419.12 (non-refundable, for exactly the same flights) :!:
VLM via LCY: €594.44 (refundable).

One more reason not to fly LCC (!) VLM. ;-) Furthermore, with VLM I should have left at 7:20 instead of 9:30 (so I stayed in bed two more precious hours), and I would have come back at 22:30 instead of 19:55 (I was in the arms of my beloved wife two and half hours earlier :) ).

No, VLM is not really an option for a hurried businessman.

PS: I had a refundable ticket for flexibilty.
André
ex Sabena #26567

User avatar
Comet
Posts: 6481
Joined: 05 Jul 2003, 00:00
Location: Scarborough, North Yorkshire, England
Contact:

Post by Comet »

Tip for cheaper SNBA tickets - Expedia and the SNBA website itself - both quoted me the same price for my March flights. They are rigid in not allowing changes, but they are at times I want so I wouldn't be changing anyway!

I think you need to shop around alot with internet buying though. I checked out a day trip from BHX to Jersey with Flybe for 12th May - less than £100 for a morning flight out and evening return (I think it was £56) but the same flights on the same day from Expedia were about £90 more!! I know who I prefer to buy from in that example!

If VLM are "low cost" how come it can cost over £100 from LCY to BRU when it is only costing £96 with SNBA? And you get the full service with VLM like you do with SNBA. From what I read about SN their service is identical to that of VLM.
Sabena and Sobelair - gone but never forgotten.
Louise

User avatar
Comet
Posts: 6481
Joined: 05 Jul 2003, 00:00
Location: Scarborough, North Yorkshire, England
Contact:

Post by Comet »

sn26567 wrote:
EI BAe 146s were 6 abreast, but they weren't that bad.
Maybe for small people, but if you weigh 80 kg for 1.83 m, they are too small, whatever the airline. An Avro is built to have 5 seats abreast, not 6. And the airlines that put 6 seats are cheating their customers.
Sorry I didn't see this part of the message before. How tall is 1.83m in feet and inches? Is it tall? I agree that six abreast in an Avro can be cramped, but what I also mean is that the seats themselves on the Aer Lingus aircraft were nice and comfortable (they were leather ones all the way through). The MD-82 was also five abreast, and that was a superb aircraft, I found.
Sabena and Sobelair - gone but never forgotten.
Louise

User avatar
Comet
Posts: 6481
Joined: 05 Jul 2003, 00:00
Location: Scarborough, North Yorkshire, England
Contact:

Post by Comet »

You say that VLM is not for businessmen in a hurry - most of their passengers are commuters who travel between the UK and Belgium in the same day!
Sabena and Sobelair - gone but never forgotten.
Louise

User avatar
sn26567
Posts: 40845
Joined: 13 Feb 2003, 00:00
Location: Rosières/Rozieren, Belgium
Contact:

Post by sn26567 »

Comet wrote:You say that VLM is not for businessmen in a hurry - most of their passengers are commuters who travel between the UK and Belgium in the same day!
Yes, but not to Manchester!
André
ex Sabena #26567

User avatar
Avro
Posts: 8856
Joined: 28 Apr 2003, 00:00
Location: Belgium

Post by Avro »

Thanks for this very nice report André.

It's a pitty you got the BA 6 abreast Avro :cry:
BA: €309.12 (non-refundable)
SN: €419.12 (non-refundable, for exactly the same flights)
It's amazing that the prizes aren't the same or nearly the same :confused:
VLM via LCY: €594.44 (refundable).
That's indeed a very expensive LCC :lol: :lol:

Greetz
Chris
8)

User avatar
Comet
Posts: 6481
Joined: 05 Jul 2003, 00:00
Location: Scarborough, North Yorkshire, England
Contact:

Post by Comet »

VLM are expensive because they ain't a low cost carrier :lol:

Will really miss them this year - and LCY. Manchester has a flat boring approach, and LCY with an Avro is not as good as LCY with a Fokker 50. I have filmed both types on the approach, and no aircraft dives as steeply as the Fokker on the final descent!
Sabena and Sobelair - gone but never forgotten.
Louise

User avatar
Avro
Posts: 8856
Joined: 28 Apr 2003, 00:00
Location: Belgium

Post by Avro »

Comet wrote:VLM are expensive because they ain't a low cost carrier :lol:
That's not what they are saying ;)
Comet wrote:Will really miss them this year - and LCY. Manchester has a flat boring approach, and LCY with an Avro is not as good as LCY with a Fokker 50. I have filmed both types on the approach, and no aircraft dives as steeply as the Fokker on the final descent
Why have you chosen SNBA if you don't want to miss LCY with the F-50 ? :roll:

Ciao
Chris
8)

User avatar
Comet
Posts: 6481
Joined: 05 Jul 2003, 00:00
Location: Scarborough, North Yorkshire, England
Contact:

Post by Comet »

We chose SNBA because we always liked Sabena and we wanted to try SNBA, but SNBA don't use LCY like Sabena did, so we have to put up with Manchester.

I have no doubt at all that I will love flying with SNBA but I will still miss VLM because I flew with them for the past couple of years.
Sabena and Sobelair - gone but never forgotten.
Louise

User avatar
A318
Posts: 1721
Joined: 13 Aug 2003, 00:00
Location: Between here and there
Contact:

Post by A318 »

Comet, you really know how to create your own perfect VLM world!
I should call them one time and tell the management they are not a LCC, maybe they change their minds in the future, or they even ask oyu to be the new CEO!!!
Dream on girly and get serious.

Erwin
A Whole Different Animal

OO-SBZ
Posts: 1096
Joined: 17 Jul 2003, 00:00

Re: BRU-MAN with SN, MAN-BRU with BA (13 Jan 04)

Post by OO-SBZ »

sn26567 wrote:2. MAN-BRU BA1620

What a difference for the return flight! I tried to check in at a BA automatic machine, but it did not accept my ticket because it was issued under an SN number. I thus had to queue, and the line was much longer than in Brussels. I got seat 10A. I did not notice any special planes during my wait.

Boarding was on time. The aircraft was an Avro RJ100 of Bristish Airways CityExpress; I did not even bother to check the registration after I saw the seating, but it looked like this:
Image
Seating was, as I feared, 6 abreast, although with leather seats. But in C class, the seats were five abreast, and there were 7 passengers for seven rows (meaning a load factor of only 20%). In economy, for the remaining rows, load factor was 65%. That means that there should have been less rows in C and more in Y.

Nevertheless, there were two neighbours on my right side, and we were like sardines in a box. Departure was on-time at 17:30 and smoother than in the morning flight.

The meal was a single all day deli (mozzarella and onion marmelade on tomato bread: surprising, but not bad). It was quickly served, as there were no less than 4 stewardesses on board (here the number can replace the quality). With that I had a 33 cl can of the only available beer: a UK-brewed Stella Artois. That was also OK.

Brussels was reached in one hour, and after some delay at getting to the gate, I disembarked on time at 19:55.

I said "never again in an Avro with 6 seats abreast", and I confirm; but when you have in a hurry to get home and no other choice, except waiting two and a half more hours for a SN flight, what do you do?
Thanks for the very detailled report :thumbsup2:

No wonder SNBA is such a success in the UK!

From my ARJ 85's rememberances (12/1997 and 11/2003) I would not like to sit in the 6 seats abreast configuration :cry:


BeN :idea:

User avatar
gliding-glider
Posts: 189
Joined: 02 Jun 2003, 00:00
Location: a nice place in Belgium

Post by gliding-glider »

André,

As far I understand, your flight was OK after-all (and safe).
It's obvious that for the amount you paid (unfortunatelly) you would have expect (at least a little) more ..... but that's the market/(code share agreements) at the moment. No competition, .... pay the price (and remember this is a high yield/demanded route).
I agree that as a business men, you look for time/facility ... that's obvious.
It's quit normal, I wouldn't do (or didn't) otherwise.
VLM wouldn't have been any advantage at all ... au contraire !
I have nothing against VLM, but I do agree with the statement of A318.

Greetz,

User avatar
L-1011
Posts: 940
Joined: 10 Jul 2003, 00:00
Location: Royal Observatory of Belgium, Brussels

Post by L-1011 »

Thanks for this excellent trip reprot André!!

This makes people appreciate even more the 5 abreast configuration of SN.

As you said that your return flight was not full, I was wondering how many times the 6-abreast Avro's have an 100%LF, and if the sacrifice of some seats would not benefit most operators of that type.

ciao,
TriStar :)

User avatar
Comet
Posts: 6481
Joined: 05 Jul 2003, 00:00
Location: Scarborough, North Yorkshire, England
Contact:

Post by Comet »

A318 wrote:Comet, you really know how to create your own perfect VLM world!
I should call them one time and tell the management they are not a LCC, maybe they change their minds in the future, or they even ask oyu to be the new CEO!!!
Dream on girly and get serious.

Erwin
Erwin - can you please tell us all how many times you have flown with VLM that you are such an expert on their in-flight service?

I would really love to know :!:

If you look at their prices from the UK to Belgium you will see that they are anything but "low cost", indeed SNBA are cheaper! (And I am not very happy at SNBA at the moment :evil: :evil: :evil: )
Sabena and Sobelair - gone but never forgotten.
Louise

User avatar
Comet
Posts: 6481
Joined: 05 Jul 2003, 00:00
Location: Scarborough, North Yorkshire, England
Contact:

Re: BRU-MAN with SN, MAN-BRU with BA (13 Jan 04)

Post by Comet »

sn26567 wrote:

when you have in a hurry to get home and no other choice, except waiting two and a half more hours for a SN flight, what do you do?
You go on one of these of course :lol:
Image

What is it? It's the interior of a Fokker 50 that's what!!

Who does it belong to? VLM, that's who. The same VLM who have never screwed up my flight reservations!!!!!!!!

Now that is what I call a comfortable interior (and those seats have a 32" pitch). For a small aircraft they are very comfortable.

Roll on VLM again in 2005!
Sabena and Sobelair - gone but never forgotten.
Louise

User avatar
Sabena_690
Posts: 3378
Joined: 20 Sep 2002, 00:00

Post by Sabena_690 »

STOP it NOW. Comet: I don't want to hear one word anymore about VLM in this topic, ok?

Fantastic and well written report, André! I'm surprised the load factor was quite low.

I wondered about one thing: why didn't you check in for your MAN-BRU together with your BRU-MAN? It would surprise me when SN wouldn't allow this when the flight is operated by BA.

Frederic
Brussels Airlines - Flying Your Way

Post Reply