Law firm files lawsuits on behalf of the family of a humanitarian Italian couple that died in the Ethiopian Airlines Boeing 737 Max 8 crash


Two federal wrongful death lawsuits were filed on May 2 in Chicago, IL by the law firm Kreindler & Kreindler LLP, along with co-counsel Power Rogers & Smith LLP, on behalf of the family of Carlo Spini and his wife Gabriella Viciani, of Sansepolcro in the Arezzo Province, who were killed in the crash of the Boeing 737-8 MAX, operated as Ethiopian Airlines Flight 302 on March 10, 2019 in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. The defendants in the case are Chicago-based Boeing Company and Rosemount Aerospace, Inc. of Minnesota. The lawsuits were filed in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois.

The lawsuits make a damning case against Boeing and the Federal Aviation Administration’s failures that caused the crash, including allegations not found in prior lawsuits that Boeing failed to activate an important safety feature in the aeroplane and that Boeing failed to have its MCAS consider flight variables such as the aeroplane’s airspeed and altitude before triggering and pushing the aeroplane’s nose down toward the ground.

The victims had been a vital part of the healthcare community in Florence and Arezzo, as well as in developing countries. Dr. Spini was a retired physician from Sansepolcro, having spent more than three decades in general medicine and surgery at Careggi Hospital in Florence, Hospital of Pieve Santo Stefano and Sansepolcro Hospital in Arezzo.

Spini, along with his wife, Viciani, a nurse, had been travelling to Africa since 2002, when they established a program for the prevention of AIDS/HIV transmission, and treatment of other diseases, in Malawi. Successive projects in the following 16 years until their deaths included the creation and oversight of 11 hospitals and healthcare clinics in Kenya, Malawi, Eritrea, South Sudan, Madagascar and other countries in need.  At the time of his death, Spini was President of Africa Tremila, a non-profit based in Bergamo, which establishes and oversees humanitarian programs in developing countries. Spini and Viciani were on board ET 302 en route to an Africa Tremila project in Kenya. In addition to their four children, Andrea, Francesco, Marco and Elisabetta, Spini and Viciani are survived by eight grandchildren. The Spini/Viciani’s home in Sansepolcro was the social centre for the entire Spini family.

Our parents committed themselves to the welfare of others.  We are saddened by the loss of our parents, but above all, we are angry at Boeing for depriving our family, friends and the many needy people in Africa, of these two, special people. The hundreds of messages received from all over the world have shown that our parents committed themselves every day to help others in need. They lived and worked together for over 50 years, providing care in hospitals and on missions, committed to the welfare of others,” said Andrea Spini, their eldest son.

Justin Green, a Kreindler & Kreindler LLP partner and a military-trained pilot, said, “Boeing made inexcusable errors in its programming of its Maneuvering Characteristics Augmentation System (MCAS).  The most important, and one that has not yet been addressed, is that MCAS does not consider the airplane’s proximity to the ground when making its decision to push the nose down and that Boeing failed to introduce a ground proximity avoidance system for the airplane.  Boeing designed the MCAS so that it did not even consider the accurate data supplied by the airplane’s second angle of attack sensor and that it would not reject completely implausible data supplied by the failed sensor that indicated that the airplane was over 74 degrees nose high. Boeing’s MCAS design permitted a single point failure of an AOA sensor to cause two aviation disasters and is perhaps the worst design in the history of modern commercial aviation.

We are seeking punitive damages because strong public policy in Illinois supports holding Boeing accountable for its intentional and grossly negligent conduct, in particular its refusal, even today, to admit that the grounded Boeing 737-8 MAX had any safety problems even while the plane is grounded and Boeing is being forced to finally fix the problem that has caused two aviation disasters in the short life of the airplane,” said Todd Smith, partner and lead counsel from Power Rogers & Smith L.L.P.

The complaint filed today on behalf of victims’ family summarizes their claims, in part, as follows:

Boeing put its financial interests ahead of the safety of passengers and flight crews when it rushed the design, manufacture and certification of the Boeing 737-8 MAX, and when it misrepresented to the public, the FAA, and Boeing’s customers that the airplane was safe to fly, which Boeing shockingly continued to do even after the crash of ET302.

Boeing intentionally hid from its customers, including Ethiopian Airlines, that the Boeing 737-8 MAX had an aerodynamic handling defect and that it had installed MCAS in its 737-MAX airplanes to address the defect.

Boeing obtained FAA certification for the Boeing 737-8 MAX by intentionally, recklessly and/or negligently underestimating the odds that MCAS would erroneously force the airplane’s nose down and by overestimating the ability of pilots without MCAS training to respond to MCAS-created handling emergencies.

Boeing represented to the FAA that MCAS was a benign computer code programmed in the airplane’s Flight Control Computer that would cause Boeing 737-8 MAX to “feel” to its pilots like it handled the same as the Boeing 737NG; to the contrary, MCAS was a deadly defective feature.”

Anthony Tarricone, also a partner and of the Kreindler firm, said “The case will focus, in part, on the intertwined relationship between the Federal Aviation Authority (FAA) and Boeing, which allows Boeing engineers to act as designated FAA safety inspectors during the certification process. That the 737-8 MAX was certified as safe without the MCAS and its failure modes being subjected to rigorous testing and analysis illustrates that the FAA has been captured by the industry it is supposed to regulate. Industry lobbying focused on elevating corporate profits over passenger safety does not promote certification of safe airplanes.

On 5 May, The Wall Street Journal published an article showing that Boeing knew of the MCAS and AOA problems one year before the first crash (Lion Air). Boeing responded that the aircraft was safe to fly, even with special training.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.